| dates | August 2025-April 2026 |
| word count | 20000 |
Nuclear Shadows was my yearlong senior thesis project and the capstone achievement of my film studies degree. In this thesis, I argued that there were aspects of American culture that were direct subconscious responses to the development of the nuclear bomb in the 1940s and evaluated two different patterns of reparative thinking that I believed related to the bomb: the adaptation of ancient Pueblo metaphysics and cosmological belief systems to a colonized and technologized New Mexico desert, and the organic manifestation of the UFO myth and the subsequent proliferation of conspiratorial thought among modern Americans.
The final thesis is the product of a huge amount of shifting and narrowing of scope, and many thousands of hours of research into American nuclear military operations, radioactive contamination, environmental anxiety, eschatology and apocalypse cults, 20th century American culture and more became either background research or irrelevant to the resulting argument, though I consider this research process to have been an incredibly valuable learning experience that I will be building on indefinitely in my career and my personal research interests. In addition to this academic research process taking place in libraries and databases, I had the opportunity to travel to New Mexico and speak with dozens of individuals about my project and about their experiences with nuclear science, UFOs, cosmological coincidence and resonance, and technoscientific nuclear colonialism. This trip was incredibly constructive and validating, and helped to ground and contextualize the research I had done about sites and locations I previously had no mental image of.
Hindsight is 20/20 and on revisiting this piece of writing months after completion, there are many things I wish I had changed; despite this, I’m incredibly proud of the final product and of my tenacity in bringing this beast to the finish line fully-formed. The Reed College thesis is notoriously stressful and it’s a huge relief to have closed the door on a project that was ever-present in my mind for well over a year.
Below, I’ve presented a substantially abridged version of the latter chapter, preserving the majority of the analysis and discussion of Yorgos Lanthimos’ Bugonia and Ari Aster’s Eddington.
Fear of the Dark
There’s tunnels under the lab, they tell me. Under the lab and under the town too, they think, and technically nobody’s supposed to know about them but everyone does. Most people we talk to don’t understand the curiosity, aren’t sure what’s exceptional about their quaint town in the desert. But Los Alamos unsettles its teenagers the same way it unsettles me, and anyone before them who felt the same left the moment they got the chance. The young people of Los Alamos, the true born-and-raised locals—they’re the ones who tell me about the tunnels and the lights over the mountains, and about the burner phone at their dad’s bedside that rang, once, in the middle of the night. They have Roswell stickers on their water bottles and shoot furtive glances around empty rooms before saying things they think they shouldn’t. They’re the ones with theories about what happens here in the dark, and they’ve been waiting for someone to listen.
This chapter deals with fears and concerns about what happens behind the veils of government secrecy and security, and the tendency of the human mind to rationalize and fill gaps in perception or knowledge. Presented with an absence of information, internal or external, the natural instinct is to discover or insert truths in order to explain the gap. A frequent recurrence in alien abduction narratives is the question of whether the experience was truly CSA (childhood sexual abuse), or vice versa. This connection is seen emerging in the early 1990s, explored in depth in a psychoanalytical study by Michael Persinger into the phenomenon of ‘sudden remembering’, and in pop culture in David Lynch’s Twin Peaks (1990), a 1996 episode of The X-Files titled “Paper Hearts,” and Gregg Araki’s Mysterious Skin (2004). The presence of a gap in childhood memory causes fear and uncertainty about what may have happened, and the natural instinct is to create or find an answer for a gap. CSA and abduction can both explain gaps in memory as well as other signs of post-traumatic stress particularly relating to sex or intimacy; as a result, the two can be conflated or substituted for each other and the confusion between the experiences of abduction and CSA can render the repressed or unconscious memories even more traumatic through their ambiguity and uncertainty. The media connection between the two arises because the answer is inherently ambiguous and unsolvable, and the experiences can be metaphoric substitutes for one another in ways that problematize memory and knowledge.
Though abduction frequently evokes sexual trauma, encounters with the sublime and terrible can constitute traumatic experiences themselves. Anthropologist Susan Lepselter takes pains to take an “experience-centered” approach to her subjects’ stories, prioritizing affect and trauma over questioning the veracity of their claims. She draws from the work of David Hufford, who theorized that sleep paralysis is a universal occurrence that may underlie many traditions of traumatic uncanny attack. However, rather than dismiss the uncanny memories, his respectful and careful study emphasized the primacy of human embodied experience, as a way to insist on the phenomenological reality of stories that might easily be seen as folklore in the sense of fiction.
Centering experience over perceived validity not only deconstructs assumptions of power inherent in definitions of the real but allows for an elusive or unspecified referent of trauma to be considered seriously. As her ethnographic study of abductees focuses on the rhetoric of apophenia, Lepselter is careful to be mindful of power dynamics implicit in psychological and diagnostic criteria and to use these terms not as value judgments but as descriptions. She writes:
Apophenia refers to the experience of perceiving connections between random or unrelated objects. This definition, though, already contains within it a specific point of view, an assumption of power. Who decides what is really related or unrelated? Who defines whether the relations between objects—or between events, or between spectacles of dominance across various contexts—are random and arbitrary?
This consideration of power allows for an open-minded analysis of post-traumatic experiences and coping mechanisms even when the referent is ambiguous. Roger Luckhurst writes that “although alien abduction is not true, it is also not simply false, for textual distance from abductees should not … efface the very real traumatic response that people actually experience, however ‘fictive’ the category.” In fact, an ambiguous and referent-less trauma evokes the concept of the uncanny, in the sense of the familiar becoming in some way strange or alien, and implying that defamiliarization is not just a symptom of trauma but the root cause of it. Defamiliarization, or the development of an awareness of the uncanny, is a gradual process rather than a catalyzing event. In these cases, abduction can be an explanatory stand-in for the traumatic event; in other words, “in order to yield significant meaning, memories of uncanny trauma do not necessarily have to be reduced to a question of whether the abduction ‘really happened’—something impossible to assess after the fact in any case.”
It is important to note that, while not exclusively, the vast majority of abductees, experiencers, and UFO believers are white and middle class. In a sense, abduction stands in for a sense of subjugation that people and families of European descent have no direct analogue for. Lepselter’s subjects feel that
something is wrong, but no one knows what. No one talks about power as class in these stories, nor as a national foundation of slavery and the genocide at the base of American colonization … but disturbing free-floating after-images of enslavement and colonization remain, gathering in distorted forms, in discourses from people with no direct birthright to those traumatic histories.
Extraterrestrial visitation and abduction, and the collaboration of the government in concealing its occurrence and existence, becomes the default mode of reckoning with the feeling of oppression and is subconsciously affirmed by the cultural legacy of American slavery. It is because of this conflation between subjugation and outside forces that believers tend to be white, as they are the least likely to recognize or have been victims of colonial violence in the United States.
Lepselter bases her argument on the dual thought patterns of apophenia and resonance, which she observes in her ethnographic subjects in Rachel, Nevada, and Hillview. Though she focuses on communities of UFO experiencers in her research, she characterizes these models of reason as being hallmarks of American fringe communities concerned with experiences of the uncanny. She defines the terms:
In mainstream psychology, apophenia is called an “error of perception … the tendency to interpret random patterns as meaningful” (Hoopes 2011). But the people I write about here cultivate apophenia, not as an “error,” but instead as a way to begin seeing those things that have become invisible. They foreground the naturalized patterns that normally go without saying…. The people here pay close attention to parallels and resemblances between stories. And the parallels produce a feeling of, and an aesthetic sense of, resonance …. The sense of uncanny resonance becomes an expressive modality, a vernacular theory, a way of seeing the world, an intimation of the way it all makes sense.
Lepselter’s resonance is a kind of inverse of the sense of the uncanny; where uncanny is the feeling “something is wrong” or unfamiliar, resonance is the feeling that “it all makes sense.” Resonance becomes a reparative companion to the uncanny thought patterns generating “free-floating anxiety in the room.” Patterns of resonant thinking recur in works of fiction about UFOs as they do in folk stories and personal recountings of UFO encounters and indicate the rationalization of trauma in much the same way Lepselter describes in her ethnographic analysis of these communities.
Across a variety of films, this chapter documents UFO encounters both as traumatic experiences and as metaphors for trauma, the motivation to make sense of traumatic experiences and seek the truth behind their occurrence, and the way these thought patterns distort and manifest in modern conspiracy rhetoric. Nope (Peele, 2022) depicts how a UFO encounter can itself be traumatic by analogizing it to the way animals react violently in response to fear of the unnatural or unknown. Close Encounters of the Third Kind (Spielberg, 1977) was one of the earliest and most prominent films to place abductees in opposition to secretive government operations, portraying affective remembrance of the trauma as a motivator for seeking the truth behind the trauma. Bugonia (Lanthimos, 2025) depicts a CSA survivor’s search for truth and meaning within alien conspiracies, while Eddington (Aster, 2025) explores remarkably similar conspiratorial and resonant thinking without the constraints or fantastical aspects of the UFO narrative. In analyzing the role of trauma and resonance in each of these works, we see a direct link to apophenia and paranoia and the evolution of these thought patterns alongside modern politics.
He thinks he’d blow our minds
Trauma is a paralyzing, immobilizing force. Without a referent, the cause of the trauma is nebulous or unidentifiable entirely; “the memory seizes you, descends on you; and the traumatized person herself becomes ‘the symptom of a history [she] can not entirely possess.’” Luckhurst argues that the rise in abduction narratives is “an unforeseen ‘explanation’ of trauma,” giving victims language and models of experience through which to process their emotional affect. Conspiracy and trauma both concern themselves greatly with the gap, with the conspicuous absence, with “missing documents or silenced speech, and the furious activity of filling the holes by narratorially ingenious connections—provided, once more, by [science-fiction].” Abduction narratives alone cannot contain the entirety of traumatic explanation within themselves, and leave too many factors up for potential explanation; the rise of the government conspiracy theory in abduction narratives becomes a new locus of explanation and concealed truth through which experiencers can externalize and centralize the source of their trauma.
UFOs came into the American consciousness in the tense and fearful period following the conclusion of the World War II and gearing into the Cold War. During the summer of 1947, flying saucer sightings were reported across the country by military personnel and civilians and launched an Air Force investigation into the phenomenon. In the midst of this, rancher Mac Brazel found a debris field of rubber, foil, tape, paper, and wood on his ranch in Corona, New Mexico. After a neighbor told him the material might be related to the flying saucers, he reported it and Major Jesse Marcel of the RAAF (Roswell Army Air Base) retrieved it. Air Force General Ronald Ramey announced that the debris was from a high-altitude weather balloon, and the matter lay dormant for thirty years.
In 1978, the incident was brought to the forefront of the public imagination again by ufologist and former nuclear physicist Stanton Friedman. Friedman interviewed Jesse Marcel, now a retired Air Force Colonel, who said he had been ordered to remain silent and stand by the official account. The debris, Marcel described, contained “metal like tinfoil” that could not be cut, torn, or even dented. All of it was covered in symbols “that we had to call hieroglyphics because I could not understand them.” Marcel was convinced “it was definitely not a weather or tracking device nor was it any sort of plane or missile. What it was, we didn’t know.” What’s more, the material that contained hieroglyphs was not presented at General Ramey’s press conference. Marcel felt that he had been made complicit in an attempt by the Air Force to lie to the American public.
Friedman’s investigation, and subsequently Charles Berlitz and William Moore’s 1980 book The Roswell Incident, sparked renewed curiosity and suspicion about the government activities in Roswell in 1947. The fascination snowballed and became a national obsession by the 1990s, resulting most notably in Chris Carter’s TV show The X-Files. The premise of The X-Files is that there exists a massive, meticulously organized cover-up of aliens and paranormal phenomena by a shadow agency unknown even to federal intelligence agents. Highlighting tensions within the FBI, across different agencies, and between intelligence and the military from the earliest episodes, the show affirms the paranoiac’s suspicions by diegetically confirming the orchestrations of secrecy and concealment within the government. UFO narratives concerned with government operations offer two possibilities:
either the government knows about abduction and is executing ‘the most aggressive and ingenious cover-up in history’ (Lindemann 11), or the government knows nothing, and there is barely concealed glee that ‘an intelligence from somewhere else is…bypassing political structure, is bypassing governmental censorship’ (Linda Howe in Bryan 164). Either the military is experimenting with alien technology, or it is desperately powerless in the face of massive and systematic intrusion.
Even when the CIA and Air Force began to admit to their deception in the 1990s, “such admissions did not restore credibility but only deepened cynicism.” The damage had already been done and the admission only gave believers more reason to be suspicious of any statements coming out of federal agencies or the military. Now, more than ever, anything they said must be a lie because it had been a lie before.
The arrival of alien spacecraft, in Close Encounters and Nope and countless other stories and films about abduction, is signaled by the sudden disappearance of stars in the night sky. Absence signals a presence. The idea that nothing is there or something is there becomes nothing is there so something is there, a paradox that nevertheless becomes a revelation by conspicuous obscurity. Kerry Howley argues that Trump gained immense support during his 2016 presidential campaign from voters who were otherwise suspicious of the government, because he “pointed to an absence and projected upon it an imaginary world.”[9] Calling attention to the structures of secrecy put in place by the government apparatus allowed Trump to harness the logic of apophenia and conspiracy, suggesting gaps to be filled by invented truths. Luckhurst identifies the impetus of the abduction scenario as “the nagging sense of a gap that structures memory by its absence.”
Trump’s 2016 campaign, while not solely responsible, marks the turning point at which conspiracy became the fulcrum of US politics. His strategy relied on sowing distrust in the government among the American people, the intelligence community being his primary target. “Instead of objecting to their individual crimes,” writes Howley, “he drew attention to the whole structure—a secret, parallel government of officials running secret programs with secret money. Trump supporters could not know what went on at Langley or Fort Meade and so Donald Trump painted a picture for them: a bunch of men no one had elected, whose names no one knows, conspiring to destroy the man they had chosen to lead them.” The “secret parallel infrastructure” of the American government’s intelligence operations, while entirely real and well-documented, closely resembles the “architectures of conspiracy, webs of the powers that be” recurrent in the resonant thought of Lepselter’s subjects.
Resonance, as a practice of finding meaning in secret or occult ways, lends itself easily to paranoid or conspiratorial tendencies. “The events or images themselves are meaningless. It is when they are suddenly revealed as connected to each other in a single structure that their connection grows charged with the intimation of hidden significance, a ‘secret meaning,’ Freud says, or an intuition of relations that seem to be—somehow—purposefully constructed.” The urge to seek truth and hidden significance is prevalent in these narratives about government concealment and secret architectures, and makes these narratives potent settings for stories about characters trying to find reasons for or make sense of traumatic events.
New regimes, old ideas
Yorgos Lanthimos’ Bugonia depicts the extremes of conspiratorial and paranoid thinking through the character of Teddy (Jesse Plemons), who kidnaps pharmaceutical CEO Michelle Fuller (Emma Stone) to prove that she is secretly an alien. Teddy’s life has been permanently altered by a single tragic event he can pin directly on Michelle’s company, Auxolith: his mother has fallen into a coma following an unsuccessful clinical trial to treat her opiate addiction, and all he received in return was a settlement and a personal apology. Teddy lives in his mother’s home and keeps it unchanged, and he works in an Auxolith fulfillment center with a framed portrait of Michelle in the break room. His subsequent turn to conspiracy theories, particularly regarding colony collapse disorder, is clearly known by the rest of the characters in the film and it makes him a piteous figure in their eyes.
Though his mother’s botched treatment is the obvious inflection point for Teddy’s trauma, his rhetoric is clearly informed by concerns and caution surrounding sex and seduction. Teddy explains to his cousin Don (Aidan Delbis), who he has recruited to help him, that pollination is “like sex, but cleaner,” before convincing him to submit to chemical castration in order to “clear our heads of all psychic compulsions.” Throughout the film, a local police officer named Casey (Stavros Halkias) repeatedly inserts himself into Teddy’s life and forces interactions, pulling Teddy over on his way to work and inviting himself over to Teddy’s house without warning. During this latter conversation, Casey expresses guilt over an incident with Teddy:
Casey: Look, Teddy, man, I know it was a long time ago, what I did to you—
Teddy: It’s fine—
Casey: No. It wasn’t fine. It was wrong. But I swear, it wasn’t cause I liked it, it was just a weird power thing, that’s it. I was just young, and lost. I promise you, dude, I never ever did that to anyone else—
Teddy: Forget it. Seriously. It’s done.
It becomes immediately clear that the source of Teddy’s fear is not corporate corruption and medical malpractice, but the potential for manipulation and exploitation. The preventative measures he takes before and during his abduction of Michelle are focused entirely on protecting his mind and his reasoning.
Teddy: Right, so? What is it you admire about them?
Michelle: Bees? Um, I don’t know? Complex society… work ethic. They do their duty and they build their world without complaint. Or piety. Or self-obsession.
Teddy: Uh-huh. All true. Which is why they’re so easy to exploit, right?
Teddy does not have the luxury of having forgotten his childhood trauma, and is fixated on preventing it from happening to him again. He unconsciously reorients his life to center around his childhood trauma, but looks to the stars to find another reason for why things are the way they are that isn’t rooted in shame for him.
Part of Luckhurst’s explanation for the rise of the UFO narrative is the coinciding “emergence of abuse (sexual or otherwise) as the determining ‘secret’ of contemporary subjectivity.” In textually revealing Teddy’s childhood abuse, the referent of his trauma crystallizes into something specific and lucidly remembered rather than vague injustice by the world. His desire to reveal Michelle’s true nature is a quest not only to avenge his mother but to understand why Casey would take advantage of him; to reveal the true motive behind exploitation of vulnerable people. Teddy resembles Sedgwick’s mimetic, reflexive, faithful paranoiac, but his fascination with the extraterrestrial becomes escapist. He blames Michelle personally for, among other things, the proliferation of CCD, but still expresses his desire repeatedly to go to the mothership in order to personally voice his concerns. Lepselter describes one of her subjects who “sometimes said that only people who had gone through things in childhood were open enough to be chosen, to be abducted or taken up and out of the banal realm of everyday life. The wounds of life left you primed for a something more than this shit down here.”
“Sexual abuse,” writes Luckhurst, “is a ‘new description’ which is undoubtedly real, yet open to problematic extension through its compelling promise to deliver the final truth.” This promise is one of the driving forces of a New Mexico town’s rapid political fracture in Ari Aster’s Eddington, a cynical neo-Western set in June 2020 against the backdrop of COVID and that summer’s Black Lives Matter protests. Louise Cross (Emma Stone), wife of sheriff Joe Cross (Joaquin Phoenix), is also heavily implied to be a victim of childhood sexual abuse; rather than turning to the extraterrestrial, she runs away with cult leader Vernon Jefferson Peak (Austin Butler) after he offers a compelling description of the elite class’s global child sex trafficking ring. “When a man first came into the bar testifying the New World Order and the devious plot of all the powers that be, Randall says it stopped him dead in his tracks. It was his conversion narrative. It hit him like a bolt of lightning, he said. Because like he said, all his life he just knew that something wasn’t right. This man gave him the words.”
The patterns of resonant thinking remain even when the UFO element vanishes. Conspiracy media is pervasive in Eddington, appearing in Louise’s mother’s rhythmic chains of reason and persuasive social media monologues. In Louise’s first appearance, she has fallen asleep listening to a podcast:
Again, history repeats itself. And, uh, I mean, let’s talk about 1956. Let’s talk about the number 56 for just one minute. In California, you have Jesuit-educated Gavin Newsom. And he said to California, as he became the first governor to lock down his state, he said, “56% of you will get Corona in eight weeks.” Which is exactly 56 days. Of course, they keep looking at that lab in Wuhan, China. And if you look at that lab in Wuhan when it was established, it was 1956. Of course, that’s the year Tom Hanks was born, the first celebrity with the virus. Mr. Sleepless In Seattle. By the way, Jenny Durkan was the mayor of Seattle when it became the first city in the world outside of China to have someone get the virus. And she was the 56th mayor. This is Gematria. Ancient practice of coding numbers into words.
Though ostensibly incoherent, the monologue follows internal logic of resonant connection to make its points. Its organization is deeply intentional and convincing; the narrative is “not organized causally. It is organized mimetically, a plot of contagious magic.” An element of the abduction narrative that persists: captivity. Unlike her mother Dawn, concerned with vaccines and control and subjugation via the social contract, Louise cares deeply about the wellbeing of children, regardless of whether the danger she perceives is eminently true. She, like Teddy, has centered her trauma in her life and turned to conspiracy theory to seek an explanation for why she was abused and find courses of action to prevent it in the future. Conspiracy becomes a proactive and reparative strategy for survivors of, in this case, child sexual abuse to try and protect other victims.
The most curious parallel between these three films about paranoiacs—Close Encounters, Bugonia, Eddington—is that they ultimately all validate the paranoid beliefs held by the protagonists. Aliens are real, the government is hiding them, they’re running experiments on humanity in secret, the global elite are coordinating to create political strife, and everything is intricately and intentionally connected. Even more: none of these films allow their paranoiac protagonists to meaningfully survive past the point of revelation. Rather than integrating their conspiratorial beliefs into their worldview as fact and either resolving or continuing their paranoid tendencies, all these characters’ paths end abruptly as soon as they discover the truth: Roy boards the spaceship and leaves Earth, Joe is left profoundly disabled and unable to communicate, and Teddy is brutally killed by his own safeguard explosive vest. None of them are given the space to either accept the answer or perpetuate their paranoid tendencies, instead resolving the story at critical moments of revelation to avoid problematizing the psychology of the paranoiac.
Though these films are tonally anywhere from government conspiracy thrillers to detached, ironic depictions of the conservative mindset, the confirmation of the apparent delusion betrays a secret desire on the part of the filmmaker for there to be a reason for the way things are. The denial of post-revelation paranoid thought leads me to believe that resolution at the point of confirmation is necessary to keep the protagonists sympathetic. Then, truth becomes a secret desire of the filmmaker as much as it is an overt desire of the protagonist, offering an easy and digestible network of global connections and cooperations rather than having to accept that life is difficult and messy and unresolved and unjust. This is ultimately why I believe conspiracy can be a reparative tool: because the idea, however unlikely, of comprehending the world we live in is too tempting to forgo for a realistic worldview. It makes living in our world tolerable.
Snow falls on desert sky
The New Mexico small-town setting of Eddington is vital to its atmosphere and sociopolitical context. “This is a place where ordinary and the fantastic signs overlap. The uncanny conspiracy theory pamphlets piled on the shelves of the Little A’Le’Inn contain themes familiar to any rural libertarian with a long historical distrust of the federal government. Conspiracy theory mingles here with the cadences familiar to any small town talk.” This observation by Lepselter evokes the deterministic mythology of the Pueblo people as well as the inherent meaning read into every fragment of knowledge by seekers of resonance and truth. While there may be direct links through New Age spirituality, the marginality and isolation of the desert also contribute to this fantastical and meaning-rich atmosphere. Lepselter’s book opens with a disclaimer: “The senses of place that are deeply, ambivalently felt in people’s lives and various other places are, to be sure, components of the themes I want to explore. But this book is about neither a unified, emplaced American subculture nor a clearly marked-off genre.” This is a fragmentary community, far from homogeneity or even agreement, that nevertheless experience the world in ways evocative of the Indigenous groups they live adjacent to and in solidarity with. Nevertheless, their conspiratorial beliefs manifest in conservative politics rather than preventative or ethical practices of stewardship and environmentalism. Wheeler writes:
Patrionoia runs rampant in [Southern New Mexico]. All the ranchers and illegal immigrants and atom bomb downwinders and veterans and ufologists: all people whose love for America is outstripped only by their distrust of its government. Out in the parking lot is a Chevy Silverado with Stars-and-Stripes truck nuts hanging from a bumper stickered with the phrase LIES IN THE SKIES written in an airplane’s chemtrails. These are otherwise reasonable people, many of them kin to me, who suffer an inability to reconcile the ideology of American exceptionalism they’ve internalized with the anxiety daily seeping up out of their pores. I love these patrionoiacs and I am of their breed more than I’d like to admit, but I understand—I think—that it makes no sense.
Though they privilege synergy and resonance in their search for meaning, the lives and belief structures of experiencers and paranoiacs is inherently contradictory and works against their own interests. Despite Trump’s claims, his presidency has been no less obscure than any before him and the nuclear tensions with which experiencers are subconsciously trying to make peace with are being strained further every day. Ultimately, this is a reparative strategy far less holistic or healthy than that of Pueblo metaphysics but a reparative and protective strategy nonetheless.
